|
When |
Disadvantages |
Examples |
| Extrinsic motivation |
- Rote tasks
- Anything that emphasises repetition and practice rather than understanding
|
- Focus not on content
- Not memorised long-term
- Some forms perceived as childish
|
|
| Intrinsic motivation |
- Higher-level thinking skills
- Promoting autonomy and responsibility
- Long-term growth
|
- Difficult reaching students in larger groups
- Individual student differences
- Can be (much) more work for teachers
|
- Offering choices
- Voluntary assignments/activities
- Relating subjects to students’ own life
|
| Internalised motivation |
- Changing students’ perspective on topics and tasks
- “Teaching” enthusiasm
- Promoting autonomy
|
- Individual student differences
- Can be difficult in larger groups
- Rivalling internalisation from other sources (friends, culture, family, media)
|
- Relating subjects to students’ own life
- Use of cliff-hangers
- Use of humour
|
| Autonomy support & relatedness |
- Promoting autonomy and responsibility
- Supporting need for relatedness
- Learning to connect course to own life
- (helpful) student perspectives in course evaluations
|
- Not suitable for all students
- Often not suitable for fitst-year students
- May lead to time-consuming discussions about course structure
- Depends on subject (methods courses less suitable)
|
- Peer-feedback on assignments (See Teacher story by Toni Pape)
- Providing reasons for assignments and course components
- Putting students in charge of processes (emphasis on end result)
|
| Autonomy support & competence |
- Promoting autonomy and responsibility
- Supporting need for competence
|
- Not suitable for all students
- Often not suitable for first-year students
- Can mean more work for the teacher if things go wring
- Only suitable for stand-alone assignments
|
- Offering choices
- Voluntary assignments/activities
- Putting students in charge of processes (emphasis on end result)
|